← Back to VeloCMS Learn

membership · Oct 31, 2026

What is a membership website?

A membership website puts content or community behind an account, usually paid monthly or yearly. How it works, what it costs, and 10 ways to build one.

A membership website is a site where some or all of what you offer (articles, videos, courses, a community, downloads, a directory) sits behind an account, and people get in by joining. Most are paid, with a monthly or yearly charge that renews until the member cancels, but a membership can also be free, a one-off payment or a mix of tiers. Three parts make it work: an account system that knows who someone is, a gate that checks what they're allowed to see, and a billing system that collects money on a schedule. Everything else on this page is detail about those three parts.

I work on VeloCMS, which is one of the ten options in the build section. It gets the same questions as the rest, and its weaknesses sit right next to its features.

Last verified: 2026-10-31. Every price, fee and limit below was read on the vendor's own page that day, and each link is in the sources list. Where a page refused my fetch, contradicted itself, or labelled its prices "for reference only," I say so and leave the number out.

What is a membership website, exactly?

Paid Memberships Pro, a company that sells membership software, puts it this way: "at its core, a membership site is a place where members sign up to get access to members-only benefits." I'd keep that. The "benefits" can be nearly anything a website can serve.

Two things get confused with it.

A membership is not a store. A shop sells you a thing once (a mug, a PDF) and the relationship mostly ends at checkout. A membership sells ongoing access, which is why the money arrives repeatedly and why the work never really finishes. You're keeping a door open and giving people a reason to walk through it again next month.

A membership is also not just a login. A site can have accounts for comments or order history without gating anything. What turns accounts into a membership is the gate: some page, post, video or area a visitor can't see until they've joined (and, if it's paid, until a payment has cleared).

Free memberships are common too. Patreon's about page lists "100 million+ free memberships" next to "10 million+ fans paying for memberships each month." The free ones capture an email address and a login; the paid ones are a business model. Plenty of sites run both.

How does a membership website work?

Follow one person through it. Call her Dana.

Dana lands on a post, reads the first few paragraphs and hits a wall: the rest is for members. That wall is the gate. Behind it, the server (not the browser, because anything the browser receives can be read by a determined visitor) checks whether Dana has a session and which tier it belongs to. She doesn't, so she sees a prompt to join.

She picks a tier and enters card details. Most membership sites never touch card numbers themselves. A payment processor such as Stripe takes the payment, creates a recurring subscription, and sends the site a message (a webhook) saying "Dana's payment succeeded." The site marks her account as a member of that tier, and the gate opens.

A month later the processor charges her again. If it works, nothing visibly happens, and that's the point. If it fails (expired card, bank decline), the interesting part starts. Stripe's documentation says its billing product can "automatically retry failed subscription and invoice payments to reduce involuntary churn," recommends a setting called Smart Retries, and gives a recommended default of 8 tries within 2 weeks. Some failures can't be retried until the customer supplies a new card, such as hard declines like a stolen-card code. When retries run out, you choose what happens: cancel the subscription, mark it unpaid, leave it past due, or pause it.

So the parts, written out:

  • Accounts: a way to register and sign in again later, by password, emailed link or social login.
  • Tiers (or plans): the options on offer, such as free, supporter and premium, each with a price and a list of what it unlocks.
  • The gate: rules that connect content to tiers, like "this post needs any paid tier."
  • Billing: a processor that charges on a schedule, retries failures and lets members update a card or cancel.
  • Delivery: whatever sits behind the gate, which is what members are actually paying for.

Only the last one is yours to be creative about. The rest is plumbing, and picking a tool is mostly deciding how much plumbing you want to own.

What are the main types of membership websites?

The categories blur, and one site often mixes two. Paid Memberships Pro lists eight use cases (associations and non-profits, blogs and news, communities, courses and coaching, directories, paid newsletters, podcasting, private video); I've regrouped them the way a beginner would meet them.

Paid content and newsletters. Readers pay for writing, analysis or audio nobody else sees. Posts are the gated unit and email is usually the delivery channel. It's the simplest model to run, since it needs no live presence, only the discipline to publish on time.

Community. The product is each other: a group, a forum or a chat space, plus events. Circle calls itself "the complete community platform." The hard part is keeping conversations alive, because a dead community cancels itself fast.

Courses and cohorts. Lessons, quizzes, sometimes certificates, often drip-released so nobody binges a month in a weekend. Kajabi and MemberPress both promote course tooling.

Coaching and expert programmes. Members pay for time with a person, and the site handles scheduling, payment and a library of recordings. It's the hardest model to scale, because your hours are the product.

Creator support. Fans pay a few dollars a month because they want you to keep going, and early access or behind-the-scenes posts are the thank-you. Patreon is the best-known example.

Associations, clubs and non-profits. Dues-paying bodies such as a professional group or a hobby club. Members often get a directory, event sign-ups and a members-only news page, and renewal tends to be annual.

A useful sorting question is what the member would miss if you vanished: your words, each other, a skill, your time, or a bit of belonging. The answer changes which tool fits.

What do real membership websites look like?

I can't hand you a customer story I haven't read, so here are the publicly documented scale figures, which come from platforms describing themselves. Treat them as company claims, not audited numbers.

Patreon's about page says "300,000+ creators on Patreon" and "$10B+ earned by creators" (since 2013, per the page). Substack's says its platform has "5 million paid subscriptions," that "30%+" of them come from within Substack's network, and that "a few hundred paid subscribers at $5/month can replace a salary." That last line is marketing arithmetic, not a forecast. Ghost's front page says publications running on it earn "$100,000,000+" a year "with 0% payment fees."

Most memberships are far smaller than those. Picture (these are hypotheticals, not customers) a gardening writer keeping her best seasonal guides for paying readers, a cycling club with annual dues and a members-only route library, or a podcaster whose bonus episodes live on a private feed. Each has one gate and a modest, steady group behind it.

How do payments, fees and churn work?

Money goes sideways in three ways.

Platform fees. Some tools take a percentage of what members pay you. Patreon's pricing page says 10% "of the income you earn on Patreon," plus payment processing, currency conversion and payout fees, and applicable taxes. Substack's going-paid page says "Writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees." Squarespace charges a transaction fee on digital content and memberships that depends on your plan: 7% on Basic, 5% on Core, 1% on Plus, 0% on Advanced. Others take nothing: Ghost lists 0% on Publisher and above, and VeloCMS lists 0% on every plan. Zero isn't free, though: the tool still has a subscription fee, and processor fees still apply.

Processor fees. Whoever moves the card payment charges a cut, separate from the platform. Rates differ by country, card type and processor. I couldn't read a US figure from Stripe's page (it served me UK rates in pounds: 1.5% + 20p for standard UK cards, and 0.7% of billing volume on the pay-as-you-go plan for its Billing product), so the worked example below uses 2.9% + $0.30 per charge, which is what Kajabi quotes for its own US payments. Check your own rate. The fixed 30 cents is the sting: on an $8 charge it's 3.75% by itself.

Churn. Wikipedia defines churn rate as the proportion of customers who leave in a set period (its example: 50 lost out of 500, a 10% rate). Voluntary churn is a member deciding to cancel, which tells you something about your content. Involuntary churn is a payment failing while the member still wants to stay, which tells you something about your billing setup. A membership of 200 people with 5% monthly churn loses 10 a month, so it needs 10 new ones just to stand still.

Tax is a fourth thing, and I'm not a tax adviser. Patreon's pricing page says it takes care of "most applicable tax collections and remittance," and also lists "applicable taxes" on top of its 10% fee, so "most" is not "all." On other tools, assume the duty may land on you. Check the rules for wherever your members live.

How much does a membership website cost to run?

The tool is the visible cost. The quieter ones are hosting, a domain, payment fees and, most of all, your time producing whatever sits behind the gate.

A worked example, using only numbers I read today. Say 200 members pay $8 a month, so $1,600 gross a month. Each platform's own cut, before processor fees:

  • Patreon: 10% = $160 (plus processing, rates not shown on its pricing page)
  • Substack: 10% = $160 (the 90% figure, plus card fees)
  • Memberful: $49 flat + 4.9% of $1,600 ($78.40) = $127.40
  • Circle Professional: $89 flat (annual billing) + 2% of $1,600 ($32) = $121
  • Squarespace: 7% = $112 on Basic, 5% = $80 on Core, plus a plan price I'm not quoting
  • MemberPress Launch: 4.9% = $78.40, plus a $199.50 first-year licence and your own hosting
  • Ghost Publisher: $29 a month on yearly billing, 0% fee
  • VeloCMS Pro: $9 a month ($86.40 billed yearly), 0% fee

Then add processor fees. At 2.9% + $0.30 per charge, 200 monthly charges cost about $106.40 a month, roughly $1,277 a year. If the same 200 members paid $96 once a year instead, card costs would be about $617 for the whole year (200 charges of about $3.08). Same revenue, about half the fees. It's an illustration, not a quote, but it's the best argument for offering a yearly option.

Percentage models cost less when you're small and more as you grow; flat models do the reverse. Compare what's included before you compare the number.

Is a membership website right for you?

It's right when people already want something recurring from you and you can produce it on a schedule without burning out. Signs: readers ask where the rest of the story is, or a group wants a regular place to meet.

It's wrong, for now, when you have no audience. A paywall in front of nobody earns nothing, so build a free audience first, then gate the top slice of what you do. It's also wrong if you can't keep a schedule, since members cancel when the cadence slips.

Questions that decide it, roughly in order:

  • Who would pay, and for what: your content, your time, a group or a credential?
  • Can you deliver it every month for a year without resenting it?
  • How many members cover your costs, and can you reach that number?
  • Do you want to own your member list and brand, or rent space inside a bigger platform?

If the first two get a confident yes, build a simple version: one tier, one promise, a handful of members. Tier ladders can come later.

How can you build a membership website?

Four routes: assemble it on software you host (WordPress with a plugin), use a publishing platform with memberships built in (Ghost, Substack, VeloCMS), use a general site builder with a members feature (Squarespace, Wix), or use a creator or community platform where the membership is the product (Kajabi, Memberful, Patreon, Circle). Ten options follow, each read from the vendor's own page on 31 October 2026. The order is not a ranking, and prices change, so click through before you pay.

  • WordPress.org with a membership plugin (self-hosted; MemberPress and Paid Memberships Pro shown)
    • Price: WordPress is listed as free; hosting is separate, and its hosting page recommends Pressable, Bluehost and Hostinger with no prices. MemberPress: Launch $199.50 for the first year (listed "normally" $399), Growth $349.50, Scale $499.50. The page says "all annual renewals are at full price" but not the amount. Launch charges 4.9% per payment and accepts Stripe only; Growth and Scale list no transaction fees. Paid Memberships Pro: a free core plugin, then Standard $49 a month or $499 a year (1 site), Max $99 or $999.
    • Strong at: control and range (MemberPress lists a course builder, content dripping and, on its higher plans, more payment gateways), and the member list sits in your own database.
    • Weak at: you're the sysadmin, so updates, backups and plugin conflicts are yours. One oddity: the WordPress.org page for PMPro said it was closed on 17 October 2024 and isn't downloadable there, while PMPro's own site says the core plugin is a download. The WordPress.org notice calls the closure permanent, with the reason "Author Request," so get the plugin from the vendor and confirm.
  • Ghost (open source, managed hosting)
    • Price: Starter $18 a month billed yearly, Publisher $29, Business $199, and a Custom tier with no listed price. No monthly-billing prices or trial length are shown. Publisher and above list 0% fees from Ghost.
    • Strong at: free and paid members, tiers and email newsletters are the core of the product, per its front page.
    • Weak at: Starter's paid-subscriptions row (accepting member payments through Stripe) says "No," so paid memberships start at Publisher. The page also shows Business as 1,000 members on its card but 10,000 in the comparison; ask which is right.
  • Squarespace (hosted site builder)
    • Price: I'm not quoting plan prices, because the page text I got gave no unambiguous figure. Its Member Sites help page says "it's free to build a member site, but you need a website plan to sell memberships." Fees are 7%, 5%, 1% and 0% from Basic up to Advanced.
    • Strong at: a members area inside an ordinary, well-designed website. Recurring payments use Squarespace Payments or Stripe, and a site can offer up to 500 pricing plans, per its help centre.
    • Weak at: PayPal works only for fixed-amount, one-time payments, and the lower tiers take a visible percentage.
  • Wix (hosted site builder)
    • Price: the Pricing Plans app is "free to install" per its app listing, which lists no fees and doesn't say which Wix plan is needed. Plan prices are labelled "for reference only," so I'm quoting none.
    • Strong at: plans can be one-time, recurring or free, and can connect to pages, blog posts and bookings. The help centre says you need the Pricing Plans app and a Members Area.
    • Weak at: I couldn't find transaction fees or plan requirements on the pages I read, so the true cost is unclear until you check in the editor.
  • Kajabi (hosted platform for experts)
    • Price: Basic $179 a month or $143 a month billed annually, Growth $249 or $199, Pro $499 or $399 (these figures sat in the page's structured data; the visible plan cards showed no prices when I fetched it). Basic allows 2,500 contacts and 5 products. The FAQ says "Kajabi does not take a revenue share as a platform." Its payments run 2.9% + $0.30 on Basic for US entities, and a 2% fee applies with a third-party processor. Trial length isn't stated; plans carry a 30-day money-back guarantee.
    • Strong at: courses, coaching, communities, podcasts and newsletters under one roof.
    • Weak at: the highest entry price of the flat-fee tools I could quote, and the page showed no per-plan membership details.
  • Memberful (membership layer for your own site)
    • Price: Standard $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee; Enterprise is custom. The page says "Try it for free for as long as you like" and that you're charged only when you go live and accept payments. It doesn't say whether Stripe's fees come on top, though you connect your own Stripe account.
    • Strong at: adding paid memberships to a site you already have (a WordPress plugin, a website builder and an API are listed). It's a Patreon company, per its footer.
    • Weak at: a flat fee plus 4.9% adds up faster than a flat fee alone, and it isn't a full site platform.
  • Patreon (creator platform)
    • Price: free to start, 10% of income plus payment processing, payout and currency-conversion fees whose rates the pricing page doesn't show, plus applicable taxes.
    • Strong at: a fast route from nothing to taking monthly support, with membership tiers, community chats, newsletters and podcast tools in one place.
    • Weak at: your page lives inside Patreon, with its look, its rules and its 10%.
  • Circle (community platform)
    • Price: Professional $89 a month (2% transaction fee), Business $199 (1%), Scale $419 (1%), Circle Plus custom (0.5%). Prices are based on annual billing and exclude tax. A 14-day trial needs no card.
    • Strong at: community, events and courses, with a custom domain on every plan listed.
    • Weak at: it describes itself as a community platform, so check how well it handles a public blog, and $89 is a lot for a small group.
  • Substack (newsletter platform)
    • Price: its about page says "Substack is free to start and free to leave," and the going-paid page says writers keep 90% of revenue minus credit card fees (the about page also says "No platform fees," so read the 90% line as the one that sets your take-home).
    • Strong at: near-zero setup, free and paid posts side by side, and a built-in network (30%+ of paid subscriptions come from within it, by its own count).
    • Weak at: little design control, and the share you give up (the 10% on the other side of the 90% you keep) grows with your revenue.
  • VeloCMS (hosted)
    • Price: Pro $9 a month ($86.40 billed yearly), Business $29 ($278.40), Agency $69 ($662.40). Every plan starts with a 14-day trial that takes a card and charges on day 15; there is no free plan. Pro lists a custom domain, 5 GB and 5,000 subscribers, and every plan lists a 0% VeloCMS fee on Stripe sales.
    • Strong at: blog, newsletter, up to 5 paid tiers (monthly or yearly) and per-post gating under one login, using your own Stripe account (you paste its publishable key, secret key and webhook signing secret). Members sign in with an emailed link.
    • Weak at: gating is per post, with no category-level gate, and community means a Discord or Slack invite inside a members-only post, not a forum. It's hosted only (its developer page says "managed SaaS only"), third-party plugin development isn't open, and it's a young product with a small community.

Two patterns stand out. The percentage models (Patreon, Substack, Squarespace's lower tiers, Memberful) are cheap to start and costly to grow, while the flat-fee tools (Ghost, VeloCMS) cost more at the start and less as you scale. And the biggest difference isn't price, it's what you can take with you: your member list, your content and your payment relationships. Find the export feature and run it once before committing.

Which option fits which kind of person?

One honest line each:

  • WordPress.org with a plugin: best if you want maximum control and plugin choice and accept running a server.
  • Ghost: best for a publisher whose blog and paid readership are the same business.
  • Squarespace: best for a good-looking small site where a members area is one feature among several.
  • Wix: best for a non-technical owner already on Wix, once you've confirmed the fees.
  • Kajabi: best for an expert selling courses, coaching and community together who can afford it.
  • Memberful: best if you have a site you want to keep and only need the membership layer.
  • Patreon: best for a creator who wants support payments this week and doesn't need a branded site.
  • Circle: best when the community is the product.
  • Substack: best for a writer who values reach and zero setup over design control.
  • VeloCMS: best if you want blog, newsletter, paid tiers and a small store under one flat subscription.

When is VeloCMS the wrong choice?

Skip it if you want to host the software yourself (it's SaaS only), need a plugin that exists only in the WordPress ecosystem, want a free plan (there isn't one), or are building a community-first product with forums, chat and live events at the centre. Ghost, Circle and WordPress each do one of those jobs with more depth. It also asks you to bring your own Stripe account, which keeps payments yours but adds a setup step.

FAQ

Is a membership website the same as a subscription website?

Close, but not identical. A subscription is the billing arrangement (pay every month or year); a membership is the account and access the billing unlocks. Most membership sites use subscriptions, and some use a one-time payment instead.

Do I need a payment processor?

For paid memberships, yes. Stripe, PayPal or a platform's own payments system handles the cards, recurring charges and retries. Squarespace's help centre, for instance, says recurring payments need Squarespace Payments or Stripe.

Can a membership be free?

Yes. Patreon lists "100 million+ free memberships," and many sites use free accounts to build a mailing list before offering a paid tier.

Can I move my members to another platform later?

Sometimes. Payment relationships live with the processor, so moving subscribers usually means exporting the list and having members re-subscribe, unless the new tool can use the same Stripe account. Check export options before you build.

Last verified: 2026-10-31.

Sources (all accessed 2026-10-31)

Share this post
Report