← Back to VeloCMS Learn

newsletter · Oct 28, 2026

Is email marketing declining?

Is email marketing declining? Sourced evidence on sending volume, open rates and the Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft sender rules, plus seven email tools compared.

Not really, but it's changing in ways that hurt careless senders. The most solid evidence I could open says global sending volume fell year over year in 2025 for the first time in one deliverability benchmark's history, while inbox placement improved, and that newsletters still show up among the best-performing email programs. What has genuinely broken is the old scoreboard: open rates stopped being trustworthy once Apple's Mail Privacy Protection spread, and Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft now push back on bulk mail that skips authentication.

Quick disclosure: I work on VeloCMS, which is one of the seven tools compared further down. It sits last only because the list runs alphabetically, it isn't the right pick for most readers of this piece, and its weak spots get the same airtime as everyone else's.

Last verified: 2026-10-28.

A note on method before the argument starts. Every number below comes from a page or PDF I opened on 2026-10-28, and each link carries that date. Where I couldn't open a primary source, I say so and leave the number out. That rules out some famous statistics (more on that in the first section), and it means a few answers are "I couldn't confirm it" rather than a confident figure.

Are fewer people using email?

I'd love to hand you one clean chart of global email users. I can't. The Radicati Group's yearly email statistics report is the usual origin of those "billions of users" charts, but its website wouldn't resolve from my machine, and the Statista pages that repeat its figures keep the numbers behind a login. I'm not going to quote a forecast I couldn't read.

What I could read is the Reuters Institute's Digital News Report 2025, built on a survey of 97,055 online news consumers across 48 markets and published 17 June 2025. It asked how people came across news in the previous week. Across all markets, 45% said search, 43% social and video networks, 33% direct visits to a site or app, 21% mobile alerts, 16% aggregators and 15% email (Reuters Institute, Digital News Report 2025, Graph 29, accessed 2026-10-28).

Read that carefully, because it cuts two ways. Email is a minority route to news next to search and social, so nobody should pretend it's the front door of the internet. It's also a steady one, and the report describes email newsletters as something publishers use to build loyalty with existing audiences, adding that they "tend to perform much better with older groups." The data is about news, not marketing email, and it's a single year, so it can't show a trend. It does tell you who your newsletter might struggle to reach if your readers skew young. A newer edition exists (published 16 June 2026, 97,520 respondents, 48 markets); in the executive summary I read, I found no email figure, so the numbers above stay with the 2025 edition (Reuters Institute, Digital News Report 2026, accessed 2026-10-28).

Is the amount of email being sent shrinking?

Yes, in one benchmark, and the reason matters more than the headline. Validity's 2026 Email Deliverability Benchmark Report (covering 2025) lists as a key finding that "Global sending volume decreased YoY for the first time in this report's history as marketers prioritized smaller, higher-value lists." The report says the slowdown started when Yahoo began enforcing new bulk-sender requirements and Microsoft introduced requirements with immediate enforcement, and calls the drop "likely" the combined effect of those new guidelines and AI helping marketers "send smaller, more targeted, and higher-value campaigns" (Validity, accessed 2026-10-28).

The same report says average global inbox placement was 87.2% in 2025, a 3.7% improvement on the year before, and that Microsoft remained the hardest provider to reach at 77.4%. So fewer messages went out, and a bigger share of them landed where people look. That's a healthier-looking picture than "decline."

Two cautions. Validity sells deliverability software, so this is a vendor's report, not an independent census. And its method is seed testing: it checks where messages sent by its own consenting customers land, then aggregates the results. The report says that data "represents a snapshot in time." I'd treat it as a good indicator of direction for senders who bother to test, not a measurement of every email on earth.

Why can't you trust open rates anymore?

Because the opens aren't always people. Apple's iCloud guide says Mail Privacy Protection "hides your IP address so senders can't link it to your other online activity. It also prevents senders from seeing if you've opened the email they sent you" (Apple, accessed 2026-10-28). Apple's separate privacy page adds that the setting downloads remote content in the background, which, going by how pixel-based open tracking works (my inference, not Apple's wording), is how a message can register as opened when nobody looked at it (Apple privacy, accessed 2026-10-28).

How much of your list does that touch? Litmus publishes a monthly client breakdown built from its own platform. Its September 2026 report, drawn from over 1.5 billion opens, puts Apple at 76.56% of opens and Gmail at 16.10%, and says Mail Privacy Protection affects "roughly 55-60% of all email opens," which it calls "not considered reliable opens" (Litmus, accessed 2026-10-28). That's Litmus's own platform data, so your audience's mix may differ. The direction isn't in doubt, though.

So did open rates "decline"? Mostly they got noisy. Validity's advice is blunt: "Since Apple's Mail Privacy Protection, opens have become unreliable—and with the rise of bot clicks, clicks are suffering from the same fate," and it suggests watching conversions, site visits and replies. Litmus's State of Email page describes teams moving from opens toward revenue per email, list churn and lifetime value for the same reason (Litmus State of Email 2026, accessed 2026-10-28). If your dashboard's headline number is an open rate, the sturdiest fix is cheap: ask readers to reply, and count the replies.

What changed with Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft's sender rules?

The three biggest mailbox providers now publish minimum standards, and they've started to enforce them.

Google's sender guidelines say that from February 1, 2024, every sender mailing Gmail accounts must authenticate with SPF or DKIM, have valid forward and reverse DNS records, send over TLS, keep the spam rate in Postmaster Tools below 0.3% and follow the RFC 5322 format. Bulk senders (more than 5,000 messages a day) must additionally use SPF, DKIM and DMARC, align the From domain, offer one-click unsubscribe with a visible unsubscribe link, and stay under 0.30% spam. Google says to aim for below 0.10% (Google, accessed 2026-10-28).

Yahoo's sender hub asks bulk senders for SPF and DKIM, a DMARC policy of at least p=none, a list-unsubscribe header with one-click support, unsubscribes honored "within 2 days," and a spam rate below 0.3%, with enforcement starting in February 2024. The page, as I read it, doesn't state a daily-volume threshold (Yahoo, accessed 2026-10-28).

Microsoft's postmaster policy covers domains sending more than 5,000 emails a day to Outlook.com accounts. They need SPF, DKIM and DMARC (at least p=none), effective May 5, 2025. Non-compliant messages go to the junk folder, and if problems persist they may be rejected outright (Microsoft, accessed 2026-10-28).

For a small publisher, three practical points follow. The 5,000-a-day line is for the extra bulk rules, but Google's basic authentication and spam-rate duties apply to everyone. Your email tool should be sending from a domain you've authenticated and adding the one-click unsubscribe header automatically (ask before you buy). And a 0.1% complaint rate is a real number on a small list: one person in a thousand hitting "report spam" is enough to leave the comfortable zone, which is a strong argument for making unsubscribing easy.

Is the newsletter boom over?

I found no sign of it, but I also found less fresh data than I wanted. Substack announced 5 million paid subscriptions on March 11, 2025, "less than four months" after it passed 4 million (Substack, accessed 2026-10-28). Its About page still says "5 million paid subscriptions and counting" (Substack, accessed 2026-10-28), and I couldn't find a newer dated company figure, so I won't claim the number kept climbing.

On the marketing side, Litmus's State of Email 2026 is a survey of 500 marketing professionals in the US, UK, Australia and New Zealand (Litmus landing page, accessed 2026-10-28). Its report page says the top 8% of programs, those hitting 45:1 ROI or better, most commonly send newsletters and onboarding emails (Litmus, accessed 2026-10-28). That's self-reported survey data, so read it as a pattern, not a measured return. You'll see averages like "$36 to $42 for every dollar" repeated across blogs; I couldn't verify any of them from a primary page, so I'm leaving them out.

So the honest summary is that the format hasn't collapsed, the easy growth of the early boom may well have slowed (I can't prove that either way), and the rules of engagement got stricter. If you're deciding whether to start a newsletter now, "is email dying" is the wrong worry. "Can I earn replies from a small, real list" is the better one.

Which tools are worth using for email in 2026?

Seven options, listed alphabetically (that's not a ranking), each checked against its own pages on 2026-10-28. Prices are USD as shown that day. I've quoted what each page showed at small list sizes and avoided inventing larger tiers where the page wouldn't render them to me. Most of these companies price by audience size, so your bill will move.

At a glance:

  • beehiiv: Free plan up to 2,500 subscribers · Paid: Lite $49/mo billed yearly at 1,000 subscribers · A/B testing and automations: Lite and up · Watch for: price rises with list size.
  • Buttondown: Free up to 100 subscribers · Paid: $9 up to 1,000, $29 up to 5,000 · Automations: $29/mo add-on · Watch for: add-ons stack.
  • Ghost: No free plan listed · Paid: Starter $18/mo billed yearly, Publisher $29/mo billed yearly (1,000 members) · Watch for: Starter has no paid subscriptions or custom sending domain.
  • Kit: Free up to 10,000 subscribers · Paid: Creator $39/mo, Pro $79/mo at 1,000 subscribers · Watch for: visual automations and sequences are paid-only.
  • Mailchimp: Free up to 250 contacts · Paid: Essentials $13 and Standard $20 a month at the page's 500-contact setting (labeled "for 12 months") · A/B testing from Essentials, multivariate from Standard · Watch for: price after year one and at bigger lists.
  • Substack: Free to start · Fee: 10% of paid subscription revenue plus card fees · Watch for: no monthly fee, but a revenue share.
  • VeloCMS: No free plan, 14-day trial · Paid: Pro $9/mo up to 5,000 subscribers, Business $29/mo up to 50,000 · Watch for: no A/B testing, linear automations only.

beehiiv

beehiiv treats a newsletter as a growth business, and the pricing reflects that. The Free plan covers up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited email sends and no card. At the 1,000-subscriber setting, the pricing page showed Lite at $49 a month and Pro at $95 a month on yearly billing (monthly billing runs higher, $59 and $109 on the same page). Lite adds automations, A/B testing and paid subscriptions with a 0% take rate, though Stripe's standard 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction still applies. Lite and Pro both advertise a free trial with no card (beehiiv pricing, accessed 2026-10-28).

The comparison grid is where the ceilings live. Free has no custom automations and no A/B testing. Lite allows 10 live custom automations, 2 team seats and one paid subscription tier; Pro allows unlimited automations and paid tiers, and 10 team seats. The real catch is the slope: beehiiv's paid plans rise with list size, and a plain weekly newsletter can end up paying for growth tooling it doesn't use.

Buttondown

Buttondown is the small independent option. The base price includes a rich-text or markdown editor, sending from a custom domain and hosted archives. The pricing page's own structured data lists a free tier up to 100 subscribers, then $9 a month up to 1,000, $29 up to 5,000, $79 up to 10,000 and $139 up to 20,000 (Buttondown pricing, accessed 2026-10-28). It bills for active subscribers, which is friendlier than counting everyone who ever signed up.

The trade-off is the add-on menu. Tagging and segmentation, paid subscriptions, comments, analytics and RSS-to-email are $9 a month each; automations, multiple newsletters and archives on a custom domain are $29 each; teams and whitelabeling are $79. The base price also assumes at most one email a day to your whole list. A bare-bones newsletter is cheap, but a setup that needs automations, segments and paid tiers lands a lot higher than the headline.

Ghost

Ghost is a publishing platform where the web post and the newsletter are the same object. Its pricing page shows Starter at $18 a month and Publisher at $29, both billed yearly, and Business at $199, all set to the page's 1,000-member default; the price moves with a members slider that I couldn't read beyond that. Every plan includes unlimited email sends. Starter doesn't offer paid subscriptions or a custom sending domain, while Publisher and above add both, plus a 0% Ghost transaction fee on memberships (payment processor fees still apply) (Ghost pricing, accessed 2026-10-28).

What I didn't find on that page is a drip-sequence builder or subject-line testing. The feature comparison covers tagging, templates, multiple newsletters (1, 3 or 10 by plan), import and export, and integrations. There's a "Try for free" button with no stated trial length, and no free plan is listed. If your whole business is posts, members and a paid newsletter, Ghost is a focused fit. If you want marketing automation, you'll be wiring in something else.

Kit

Kit (formerly ConvertKit) has the largest free plan of the group. Its help center says the Free plan costs $0 as long as you stay under 10,000 subscribers, with unlimited broadcasts, forms and landing pages, tagging, segmentation, A/B testing on broadcasts, API access and the ability to sell digital products. Visual automations, email sequences and RSS campaigns require a paid plan (Kit, Free plan, dated 2026-09-23 on the page). Creator starts at $39 a month and Pro at $79, up to 1,000 subscribers, with a 14-day trial and no card; Creator allows 2 variants in subject-line tests, Pro up to 5 plus content testing, advanced deliverability reporting and unlimited team members (Kit, Creator vs Pro, accessed 2026-10-28).

One honesty note: Kit's own pricing page answered me with an HTTP 429 (a bot-challenge page) on every attempt that day, so these figures come from its help center, which lists "2 months free" for annual billing but no annual dollar amounts. The catch worth knowing is that the free plan is generous for broadcasts and thin for anything automated.

Mailchimp

Mailchimp is the old default, and its pricing page reads like it. The Free plan allows 250 contacts and 500 sends a month (250 a day). With the page's contact selector at its first band (500 contacts, USD view), it listed Essentials at $13 a month and Standard at $20, the latter after a 14-day trial. Premium showed $350, but the page's own configuration gives Premium a 10,000-contact base, so that isn't a small-list price. Each figure carries a "for 12 months" label, yet the discount the page actually describes is 15% off the first 12 months for businesses with 10,000+ contacts, so I can't tell whether $13 and $20 are list or introductory prices. The rendered page didn't show what 1,500 or 5,000 contacts would cost, so treat these as a floor, not a quote. Monthly send limits are tied to contacts: 10 times your maximum contact count on Essentials, 12 times on Standard (Mailchimp pricing, accessed 2026-10-28).

On testing, the pricing page lists "Multivariate and A/B Testing" on the Premium card, which is easy to misread as Premium-only. Mailchimp's help center says email and SMS A/B testing is included with Essentials or higher (one variable, up to 3 variations) and multivariate testing with Standard or higher, and its plan-comparison page lists A/B testing for Essentials, Standard and Premium but not Free (Mailchimp help, plan comparison, accessed 2026-10-28). The help center also notes that "non-subscribed contacts are included in your contact total and count towards your monthly contact limit" (Mailchimp help, accessed 2026-10-28), which is a quiet way for a bill to creep. The upside is a mature platform with a large integration catalogue.

Substack

Substack is the lowest-friction way to start. Its About page says "Substack is free to start and free to leave" with "no platform fees, no tiers, no contracts," yet also that writers keep 90% of revenue minus credit card fees (the page states the 90%, so the 10% platform share is implied rather than spelled out) (Substack About, accessed 2026-10-28). The features page lists drip campaigns triggered by subscriber lifecycle events (new free subscriber, new paid subscriber, founding-member upgrade, churn), custom domain support, CSV import and export, and email analytics including open rates. It mentions testing headlines for posts but, on my read, no subject-line test for emails (Substack features, accessed 2026-10-28).

The cost of that simplicity is the revenue share, which grows with your success: at 10% of a paid newsletter, the cut can exceed what the other tools here would charge in subscription fees. The pages I read were undated, so check Substack's current terms before committing.

VeloCMS

VeloCMS is a blog CMS with membership and a newsletter inside it, so email is one feature, not the product. Pro is $9 a month ($86.40 a year) with up to 5,000 subscribers; Business is $29 ($278.40 a year) with up to 50,000 and a custom sender domain; Agency is $69 ($662.40 a year) with unlimited subscribers. There's no free plan. Every plan starts with a 14-day trial, a card is required unless you have a cardless trial code, and the first charge lands on day 15 (VeloCMS pricing, accessed 2026-10-28).

On the email side, I checked the code rather than the marketing copy. It has a block-based campaign editor, tag-based audiences, free and paid audience filters, scheduling, a double opt-in setting, merge tags, open and click analytics, and one-click unsubscribe headers on bulk sends. Automations are linear: a trigger (signup or a tag being applied), then up to 20 delay-and-send steps. I found no A/B testing and no branching logic. On Pro, mail goes out from VeloCMS's sender, since a custom sender domain needs Business, which matters given the sender rules above. It's a young product with a much smaller ecosystem than Mailchimp, Ghost or Substack.

Who is each option best for?

  • beehiiv: writers who want growth tooling and a free tier, and who expect the list to pay for itself.
  • Buttondown: independent writers who like markdown, a small vendor and a low entry price, and can live without much automation.
  • Ghost: publishers whose posts, members and paid newsletter are the whole business.
  • Kit: creators with a big list who want a free broadcast plan and are willing to pay once they need automation.
  • Mailchimp: teams already inside it, or anyone who needs its integration catalogue more than a low bill.
  • Substack: people who want to start today at no cost and accept a 10% cut later.
  • VeloCMS: someone who wants a blog, members and a basic newsletter under one login and doesn't need deep automation.

When is VeloCMS the wrong choice?

If email is the product, pick a dedicated tool. VeloCMS has no A/B testing and no branching automations, so Kit, beehiiv or Mailchimp go deeper. If your site already lives elsewhere and you only need to send mail, moving a whole site for a newsletter feature is a lot of work. If you want a free tier, there isn't one. And if you need a big integration marketplace today, the older platforms have a head start.

FAQ

Is email marketing still worth it in 2026? It depends on your audience and how well you send. Litmus reports that the highest-ROI programs most often send newsletters and onboarding emails, though the figure is self-reported by marketers (Litmus).

Do open rates still mean anything? Less than they did. Litmus says Mail Privacy Protection touches roughly 55 to 60% of opens in its data, and Validity recommends measuring conversions, site visits and replies instead (Litmus, Validity).

Do small senders need to follow the Gmail and Yahoo rules? Yes for the basics. Google's authentication and spam-rate requirements apply to all senders; the DMARC and one-click unsubscribe duties are written for bulk senders over 5,000 messages a day (Google).

Is there a free email tool? Several, with different shapes: beehiiv up to 2,500 subscribers, Kit up to 10,000, Buttondown up to 100, Mailchimp up to 250 contacts, and Substack with no monthly fee. Ghost and VeloCMS have no free plan (beehiiv, Kit, Buttondown, Mailchimp, Substack).

Are AI inbox summaries changing email? Validity's report lists AI summaries and agentic assistants as 2025 developments and advises formatting email so machines can read it, with key information up front (Validity).

Sources (all accessed 2026-10-28)

Reuters Institute, Digital News Report 2025 · Reuters Institute, Digital News Report 2026 executive summary · Validity, 2026 Email Deliverability Benchmark Report · Apple, Mail Privacy Protection (iCloud guide) · Apple, Mail Privacy Protection and privacy · Litmus, email client market share · Litmus, State of Email report · Litmus, State of Email 2026 landing page · Google, email sender guidelines · Yahoo, sender best practices · Microsoft, Outlook.com postmaster policies · Substack, 5 million · Substack, About · Substack, features · beehiiv pricing · Buttondown pricing · Ghost pricing · Kit, Free plan · Kit, Creator vs Pro · Kit pricing (HTTP 429 on the day) · Mailchimp pricing (USD) · Mailchimp, A/B tests · Mailchimp, plan comparison · Mailchimp, non-subscribed contacts · VeloCMS pricing

Share this post
Report